Thred
All posts

How an accounting service runs when agents do the work

Follow one bank line through an accounting service where agents do the work, from payment to journal entry in two minutes, and see where the accountant still decides.

Mark Holleman6 min read

Working on this yourself? Talk to Mark, our co-founder. We’re here to solve it with you.

Book a demo
On this page

On a Monday morning at 09:40, €1,210.00 leaves a client's ING account with the description "INV 2026-0418 Van Dijk Installatie". Two minutes later the payment is booked against the right supplier invoice, the evidence is attached and the task is closed. Nobody at the accounting firm touched it.

That is what I mean by an AI-native accounting service. Look at what happens to one transaction. An agent owns it from the moment it arrives. It is finished in minutes, not when someone next opens the administration. And anyone can open the entry later and see exactly why it was booked the way it was.

Here is what happened in those two minutes. The Bookkeeper agent picked up the bank line straight after the bank sync. It found purchase invoice INV 2026-0418 for €1,000.00 plus €210.00 Dutch VAT at 21%, checked that the supplier's IBAN matched the one on file, and booked the payment against the open payable. It recorded which document, which rule and which bank line produced the entry, and wrote the result back to the client's ledger.

The rest of this piece is about what it takes to run a whole service that way, written for accounting firm partners and for finance leads deciding what their own finance function should look like.

Should agents work on the existing ledger or on a new one?

This is the first practical question, and there is no single right answer. We built two.

The first is to put agents on top of the ledger a business already uses. That is our Layer. Exact Online, Xero, Twinfield or Moneybird stays the system of record. Thred keeps a synced copy, the agents do the work there, and finished entries are written back. For a firm with hundreds of clients across several ledgers this matters a great deal. Nobody migrates anything, and the accountant keeps working where they always have.

The second is a ledger built for agents from the start. That is our Ledger. Legacy ledgers were designed for people typing in entries before a deadline. A ledger built for agents books each transaction as it happens, keeps the rules and history next to the entries, and is open over an API, so the books are current every day rather than at quarter-end.

Most firms will run both. Established clients stay on their own ledger with agents on top. New clients, or clients who have outgrown their software, start on a ledger that agents work in natively. The agents and the review flow are the same either way.

What does a month look like when agents carry the work?

The bank line above is one task. A client's month is a few hundred of them, and each has the same shape: a beginning, an end and a trail.

The Payer prepares the payment run and stops at anything above the approval limit. The Collector sends reminders on overdue invoices in the client's own tone and follows up when a customer replies. The Accountant prepares accruals, depreciation and the VAT return from a ledger that is already reconciled. Documents arrive at the client's own address and are picked up within seconds.

The biggest change is not speed on any single step. It is that nothing waits in a queue. In most firms a bill sits in a mailbox for days, gets keyed in, then waits again for the weekly bank run. When an agent owns the bill, it is checked and booked the day it arrives, and a person sees it only if something does not fit.

The trail matters as much as the speed. If you cannot open any entry and see why it was made, you cannot let software make it. We treat "explain every booking" as a product requirement. Every entry in Thred carries its source document, the rule that applied, the agent that booked it and the person who approved it, if anyone did.

What does the accountant do?

The accountant's work comes down to three concrete jobs.

The accountant writes down each client's rules. Every client has its quirks. A holding company recharges management fees each quarter. A webshop's Stripe payouts net off refunds. A consultancy bills in arrears. In Thred these live as memories, written in plain language, and every agent applies them every time.

The accountant clears the inbox. Work that falls outside the rules lands in an inbox with the evidence and a proposed answer. The accountant approves, corrects or asks the client. A correction becomes a rule, so the same question does not come back next month. In the image at the top of this post, the Collector proposes writing off a €312.40 invoice to a dissolved debtor and waits, because the amount is above that client's limit.

The accountant decides how much freedom each agent gets. Some work can run on its own from the first week, such as matching a recurring direct debit. Some should ask first, such as a write-off or a payment above a set amount. The accountant sets this per agent and per client, and widens it as the corrections fall.

What disappears is keying, chasing and checking work that was right the first time.

How can you tell the agents are really doing the work?

Because every task leaves a trail, you do not have to guess. Two things are worth looking at every week.

The first is how often a person changes what an agent booked on its own. If agents finish a lot of work but people keep correcting it, the agents are guessing. A falling correction rate is the clearest sign that the rules and memories are good enough to give the agents more freedom.

The second is how current each client's books are right now. Not "closed by the 20th of the following month", but the age of the oldest unprocessed item today. For most clients that should be hours, with the exceptions being documents the client still owes you.

How does this work for a client in another country?

Say an accounting firm in Amsterdam looks after a Dutch B.V. that opens a subsidiary in Manchester. Traditionally the firm either declines the UK work or hires someone who knows UK bookkeeping.

In an agent-run service, the firm can take it on. The Bookkeeper matches the UK bank lines, the Payer prepares the UK payment run and the Accountant prepares the UK VAT return, applying the UK rules. That means VAT at 20%, 5% or 0%, and returns submitted through Making Tax Digital compatible software. The Dutch parent stays on BTW at 21%, 9% or 0% with its return to the Belastingdienst. Services the Dutch company sells to its UK subsidiary, or to business customers elsewhere in the EU, are generally taxed where the customer is, with the customer accounting for the VAT under the reverse charge. Sales to consumers in other EU countries can be reported through the One Stop Shop.

The firm's accountants review both entities in one workspace, and a UK-qualified accountant can review and sign off what gets filed in the UK. Check the treatment of any cross-border case with your accountant, because it depends on what is sold and to whom.

What does this mean for accounting firms?

When agents carry the production work, the firm's people spend their week on review and on clients, and a new client no longer means a new hire.

It also changes what the firm sells. If books are current every day, a monthly report can become a weekly conversation. If the VAT return is prepared from a ledger that is already reconciled, the quarter-end crunch becomes a review. That is what our Accounting Firms product is built around.

What does this mean for finance teams inside a business?

For a controller or finance lead the same logic applies inside one company. Reconciliations, supplier invoices, collections and month-end accruals move to agents. The team keeps the close sign-off and the conversations with the business.

The difference shows up in timing more than cost. A team that used to discover a cash problem at month-end can see it the week it starts. A founder who used to wait for the quarterly VAT return to know where the company stands can ask on a Tuesday and get an answer from live numbers.

Where do you start?

Pick one flow where the result is easy to check, usually bank reconciliation or supplier invoices. Let agents run it for a handful of clients or one entity for a month, with every agent set to ask first. Look at what people corrected, turn those corrections into rules, and give the agents more freedom where corrections have stopped. Then move to the next flow.

If you want to try that on your own clients' books, book a demo.

Frequently asked questions

What happens to a bank transaction in an agent-run accounting service?

An agent picks up the bank line straight after the bank sync, matches it to the invoice or bill, checks details such as the supplier's IBAN, books it and attaches the evidence. The entry records which document and rule produced it. A person only sees it if something does not fit the client's rules.

How can a firm see whether agents are doing the work correctly?

Every agent task leaves a trail, so the firm can see how often a person changed an entry an agent booked on its own, and how old the oldest unprocessed item is for each client. A falling correction rate shows the rules are good enough to give agents more freedom.

Do clients have to move to a new accounting system?

No. Agents can work on top of the ledger a business already uses, such as Exact Online, Xero, Twinfield or Moneybird, and write finished entries back. A new ledger built for agents is an option for new clients or for businesses that have outgrown their software.

Can one AI-native firm serve clients in several countries?

Yes. The agents apply each country's VAT rates, filing route and chart of accounts, so a Dutch firm can look after a client's UK subsidiary from the same workspace. A locally qualified accountant should still review and sign off what is filed in each country.

How should a firm start using accounting agents?

Start with one flow where the result is easy to check, such as bank reconciliation or supplier invoices, for a few clients. Let the agents ask first for a month, turn the corrections into rules and give them more freedom where corrections stop. Then move to the next flow.

Sources

  1. VAT (Business.gov.nl)
  2. VAT rates (GOV.UK)
  3. Making Tax Digital for VAT (GOV.UK)
  4. VAT One Stop Shop (European Commission)
  5. Cross-border VAT (Your Europe, European Union)

Read next

Where Thred comes in

Accounting Firms

Make your firm more efficient with AI, so you have more time for relationships, new customers and advisory work.

Keep reading

Finance, handled.

Book a demo, or request a callback and we will call you.

Book a demo