Management accounts that start with the decision, not the P&L
Design monthly management accounts in reverse: list the calls you have to make, then add only the figures each one needs. Shown on one month of a 14-person Dutch software company.
David van Duijn7 min read
Working on this yourself? Talk to Mark, our co-founder. We’re here to solve it with you.
On this page
Management accounts are the internal figures a company produces each month to steer itself. The most useful way to design them is in reverse: write down the decisions that are due before next month, then include only the numbers those decisions depend on.
Most monthly reports are built the other way round. Someone exports the profit and loss, adds a balance sheet and the bank balance, and trusts the reader to find what matters. The reader, often a founder with a dozen other things on that week, scans the totals, sees a profit and moves on. Nothing changes, and the report slowly turns into a ritual.
We think the opening question should be different. Not "what happened in March?" but "what do we have to decide in April?"
Which decisions come back every month?
In a company of 10 to 100 people, the same few calls return month after month, whatever the sector.
- Can we commit cash? A hire, a round of laptops, a supplier prepayment, a bigger campaign. You need to know how much of the money in the bank is really yours.
- Does the plan still hold? If the month missed budget, is that timing that will catch up, or a trend that should change the forecast?
- Who do we chase, and do we keep working for them? One late customer can matter more than any average.
- Which cost deserves a conversation? Not every overspend. Only the one that is large, growing or new.
Four questions, four pieces of evidence. Every page in the report should feed one of them. A page that feeds none of them belongs in an appendix for your accountant, or nowhere.
To make this concrete, take Lindewerf B.V., an invented Rotterdam software company with 14 people, a 2026 budget and quarterly VAT returns. Below is its March 2026, organised around those four questions. The figures are illustrative and they reconcile.
Can we commit cash this month?
Start here, because this is the decision with the least room for error. Lindewerf has €146,720 in the bank on 31 March. On its own that figure flatters the business, because part of it already belongs to someone else.
- Bank balance on 31 March, €146,720
- Less VAT for the first quarter, payable to the Belastingdienst by 30 April, €26,400
- Less payroll taxes for March, also payable in April, €9,300
- Free cash, €111,020
Free cash is the number the owners should plan with. Suppose the open question is a developer starting in June at roughly €6,000 a month all in. With €111,020 free, the answer is yes, with plenty of margin. Plan with the bank balance instead and you have quietly counted €35,700 of tax money as spendable, which is how a comfortable-looking business ends up short in the week the VAT return is due.
Owners often ask why the bank rose less than the profit. Lindewerf's result for March was €7,710 while cash went up €4,420. Customers paid more slowly, adding €9,800 to trade debtors, and the company bought €3,600 of laptops and repaid €2,000 of its loan. VAT collected but not yet paid over (€8,610), more owed to suppliers (€2,350) and depreciation, which costs no cash (€1,150), pulled the other way. One short paragraph like that is enough. The decision itself runs on free cash.
Does the plan still hold?
Lindewerf budgeted a result before tax of €13,060 and made €7,710, a gap of €5,350. Putting budget and actual side by side leaves the reader to do the subtraction line by line. A bridge does it for them, one cause per bar.
Read left to right, it says two things. Gross profit came in €3,960 under budget, which is €3,600 of revenue that did not arrive plus €360 of extra direct cost. Operating expenses ran €1,390 over, made up of €400 on staff, €1,100 on marketing and €50 on software, with other costs €160 below plan.
Then comes the judgement the bridge exists for. The revenue gap is two implementation projects whose go-live moved from late March into April. The work was largely done, so its direct cost landed in March, which is why gross margin was 60.0% against a budgeted 62.0%. The invoices go out in April. That is timing, not weaker demand, so the right move is to confirm the dates with the delivery lead and leave the Q2 forecast alone, not to start cutting costs.
Who do we chase, and do we keep working for them?
Debtor days moved from 35 to 36. Looking at that ratio alone, nothing happened. Underneath it sits a single €14,520 invoice that is more than 60 days overdue, from a customer whose next project phase is due to start in April. That one invoice is about 12% of Lindewerf's €118,600 in trade debtors.
A ratio smooths out noise, and that is exactly how it hides a problem like this one. So the report should not print debtor days and move on. It should name the invoice and lay out the choice. Either an owner calls this week and the next phase starts once the invoice is paid, or the phase starts on schedule and the owners accept the risk knowingly.
Which cost deserves a conversation?
Marketing came in at €5,600 against €4,500 budgeted. It is the only cost line that moved by more than small change, and it was deliberate: a campaign started in March. The report should not present it as a failure. It should force a choice. April goes back to budget, or the owners approve an extra €1,100 a month with a target they will judge it by, such as a number of qualified demo requests.
What does the decisions page look like?
This is the page the rest of the report exists to support, and the one most monthly reports never get to. Each line carries the number behind it, the options, who decides and by when. Lindewerf's reads like this.
- One owner calls the customer behind the €14,520 invoice this week, and both owners decide by 12 April whether the next phase waits for payment.
- Both owners decide by 15 April whether marketing returns to €4,500 in April or continues at €5,600 with a demo target attached.
- The delivery lead confirms by 12 April that both delayed projects will be invoiced in April, so the Q2 forecast can stand.
- With €111,020 of free cash, the owners can approve advertising the June developer role now.
Send this page first, with the evidence behind it. If you find yourself writing eight or ten lines, most of them are tasks rather than decisions, and they belong on somebody's to-do list instead.
What can you leave out?
Working backwards also tells you what to cut. A useful test for every chart and table is to ask which of the four decisions would change if the figure were 20% higher or lower. If the honest answer is none, it goes.
For Lindewerf that removes the full balance sheet, the trial balance and the cost lines that landed within a few hundred euros of budget. They still exist and your accountant still needs them. They just do not need to sit in front of the owners every month.
How do AI agents change monthly reporting?
A report built around decisions asks for more explanation than a standard export. Someone has to find out why revenue missed, which supplier drove a cost and whether an overdue invoice is disputed or simply forgotten. That detective work is where agents earn their place.
- Variances arrive with a first explanation. An agent traces the revenue gap to the two projects not yet invoiced and drafts that note beside the bar, for you to confirm or correct.
- Decision lines get drafted, not taken. An agent can propose the line about the €14,520 invoice, with its age and the date the next phase starts. The owners still pick the option.
- Collections are already moving. By the time an owner picks up the phone, overdue invoices have been followed up and reminders have gone out on time, so the call starts from a clear history.
- Follow-up questions get answered from live numbers. When an owner asks why marketing is up, the answer is a breakdown per supplier straight away, not an email thread that runs into next week.
What stays with people is the part that matters, choosing between the options.
Where Thred fits
In Thred, transactions are processed as they happen, and accruals and depreciation are prepared for your approval, so the figures behind each decision are current instead of weeks old. The monthly board pack and ad hoc questions come straight from live numbers, and the Analyst explains what moved. That is how we approach finance for growing businesses. Thred Ledger keeps the books themselves current, and Thred Layer brings the same agents to the ledger you already use.
If your monthly report gets read but rarely acted on, book a demo and see a decisions page built from live numbers.
Frequently asked questions
How many decisions should a monthly management report ask for?
Usually two to four. Each should name the figure behind it, the options and who decides by when. When the list grows to eight or ten items, most of them are tasks rather than decisions and belong on someone's to-do list.
When does a Dutch BV have to file its annual accounts with the KvK?
A BV files its annual accounts within eight days of the shareholders adopting them, and no later than 12 months after the end of the financial year, with no extension possible. That deadline is about outside reporting. Monthly management accounts sit alongside it as an internal steering tool, so check the exact filing obligations for your company with your accountant.
Who should own each decision in a management report?
A named person, not a team. Write the owner and a date next to every decision, for example the delivery lead confirming invoice dates by the 12th. The following month's report then opens by showing which decisions were taken and what happened next.
How is free cash different from the bank balance?
The bank balance still contains money that belongs to others. Free cash subtracts what is already owed, such as VAT collected but not yet paid and payroll taxes due, so it shows what the business can actually commit. Planning with the bank balance alone can leave you short when the VAT payment falls due.
What is a variance bridge?
A variance bridge walks from the budgeted result to the actual result one cause at a time, for example lower gross profit, higher marketing and lower other costs. It shows which differences drove the gap, which a plain column of budget and actual figures leaves the reader to work out.
Sources
Read next
- Fractional CFO or a CFO agent: what each does, and the combination that works
- How to hand over accounts payable during a notice period
- Multi-currency in Xero: which plan you need, foreign invoices and bank accounts, and realised vs unrealised gains
Where Thred comes in
For finance leaders who want more capacity without more headcount.



